Germany is grappling with whether to ban the AfD, a far-right party now polling near 25% and classified as right-wing extremist by domestic intelligence. While critics accuse the party of promoting unconstitutional, exclusionary policies reminiscent of Nazi-era ideologies, AfD supporters claim banning them would be undemocratic and alienate millions. International figures have weighed in, with some U.S. politicians condemning the move, highlighting transnational far-right solidarity. Past attempts to ban extremist parties failed due to legal hurdles, fueling concerns that a failed ban could embolden the AfD. With the next election looming, lawmakers face mounting pressure—act now and risk backlash, or delay and potentially lose the legal ability to ban the party altogether. Activists warn that inaction could normalize extremism, pointing to the rise of movements like MAGA as cautionary tales.